From the desk of Alejandro:
SEVERAL weeks ago i wrote a post (here) about the 2009 vintage of Bordeaux, which is being held as the vintage of the century (which, by the way, somehow includes 1982– which in retrospect, was not that great since the wines are on their last legs) which i agree with, in spirit. The 2009’s were fabulous- but buyer be ware! Not all of it was excellent. I will continue in various parts to share my impressions and tasting notes: we start with my personal favorite; Margaux.
I will wax poetically about Margaux later- Margaux after all is known to be produce wines of feminine beauty and eternal grace. They are wines that are at the same melancholy and yet romantic; sort of like the lead of a plotless French film. YOu love it, and hate that you love it so damn much; only, because it is that sensual, that wonderful, that ethereal that loving it is somehow expected… and you hate it (and love it) and so it goes.
The following is a list of wines from the Margaux region from the 2009 vintage. The wines were all tasted March 29th in a controlled temperature room out of Riedel wine glasses. The wines were not tasted blind. All wines were barrel samples. Notes by Alejandro Ortiz.
Alejandro’s Ratings:
-
- O/P: Ok/ Poor
- G: Good
- VG: Very Good
- GR: Great
- E: Excellent (an intermediary between Great but not Fantastic)
- FA: Fantastic
- AM: Amazing
The first sub rating a “+” or “-“ is given for original impression on the nose and palate followed by a subsequent sub-rating for it’s overall performance within its rating.
- Chateau Durfort Vivens
- G+—
- Massive with layered red berry fruit
- G+—
- Ch. Dauzac
- G+
- Broody and dark, muddles flavors.
- G+
- Ch. Desmirail
- VG+–
- Deep black fruit with typical Margaux caress.
- VG+–
- Ch. Du Tetre
- VG—
- Like walking into an abandoned flower-shop. Intense, animalic, and broody with just enough floweriness to keep it pretty.
- VG—
- Ch. Kirwan
- G—
- Boring but not terrible.
- G—
- Ch. Siran
- VG++-
- Deep red with cluttered dusty flavors and velvetiness- sort of like an old stuffy yet handsome woman. That may not sound attractive, but the wine is very good!
- VG++-
- Ch. Marquis d’Alesme-Becker
- G+–
- Bitter at tasting.
- G+–
- Ch. Rauzan-Gassies
- VG—
- Taut with perfumed center.
- VG—
- Ch. Prieure-Lichine
- VG-GR
- Maybe good rather then very good, nice and layered; one of the better PL’s yet from a usually boring estate (however well intentioned).
- VG-GR
- Ch. Giscours
- VG+–
- Deep and sensuous- fabulous!
- VG+–
- Ch. Brane-Cantenac
- VG-++
- Seductive and bright- like a whisper of a long love gone
- VG-++
- Ch. Cantenac-Brown
- VG+–
- Deep ‘brown’ oak and leafy aromas.
- VG+–
- Ch. D’Issan
- VG+–
- Sensual, soft, timid and nervy- like making love to a virgin.
- VG+–
- Second Tasting @ Chateau d’Issan: FA—
- I interrupted a group of Korean delegates and was running late for another appointment but decided to be polite and taste the wine, again. I was totally surprised how different, or better, rather, the wine was. This happens, Variations are a fact of life—a side effect of a substance that is very much alive. The wine is an ethereal experience and carresesyour palate like sheets of red-stained silk duvet covers- marvelous! The second wine I fantastic- jump on this and don’t let go!
- Ch. Malescot St. Supery
- GR++
- Second Tasting @ Chateau Malescot St. Exupery: FA—
- Excellent red fruit- all the right angles of fruit, body, tannin with that silkiness and a refined acidity which betrays its patrician leanings. A fabulous wine. The second label if absolutely fantastic!
- Third Tasting @ UGG Tasting: FA+–
- See above
- Ch. Lascombes
- G–+
- Massive, mysterious aromas of myrrh and Oudh mixed with a flowers. Could be toned down.
- G–+
- Ch. Palmer (tasted at Chateau Palmer)
- FA—
- The first tasted was the Alter Ego of Palmer, the estate’s second wine; and in truth it was spectacular and huge, massive. The tannins were more than I had ever tasted in a Margaux wine. Once you peeled away the heavy curtains of beefy tannins you arrived at a chocolate and cherry center without any sort of cloying sweetness—this is a French wine at heart, no doubt about it. But the Grand Vin made this colossus seem like Tom Thumb. Had there been a seat in the tasting room I would have had to sit down once I tasted the Chateau Palmer. The Alter Ego is probably the best Alter Ego ever made. The Grand Vin; well, I’ll tell you what—after a nuclear holocaust all that’s gong to be left is cockroaches and this wine. Frankly it was tough to taste and nearly impossible to see through. This is not a reflection on the wine, but rather the limitations of the human palate. The wine, ultimately, is spectacular. If you like Palmer this is a monolithic moment for the estate. If you don’t, then I suggest you get to know it.
- FA—
- Ch. Rauzan-Segla
- GR+++
- Pure seduction, velvet fruit and spice. Fabulous!
- GR+++
- Second Tasting @ Ch. Rauzan-Segla
- Things are done a bit different at the Chateau where you’re shown a lineup of several vintages including the 1996, 2007 and the 2008 for perspective (all great by the way); which I think is quite smart. Otherwise it’s like showing a person just one chord of a concerto without hearing the rest. Rauzan-Segla is one of these wines that I am fairly convinced I could pick out blind; as I write this I can almost smell it. It has a deep undercurrent of roses and red wild flowers soaked in wine with a powderiness that makes me wonder why people don’t wear it like perfume… then of course I remember its just better to wear it. RS sometimes borders on the “… is it getting to big?” but that has never happened as the wine never seizes to amaze with its grace and balance. An amazing wine. The second label “Segla” is better than some of the past Grand Vins, and that goes true with many second wines this vintage- not to mention because most second wines are only “second” wines in spirit as they are often from different vineyard sources spiked with second-tranche barrel selections and not merely the dregs of what’s been left from its big-brother. Nevertheless- Rauzan Segla you can’t go wrong!
- Ch. Margaux
- AM+++
- It’s tough to not love Chateau Margaux and such a cliché to say “Best wine of the vintage” but if that’s what you heard—believe it. Pavillon Blanc of Château Margaux was marvelous, and one of their best so far—it has moved away from it’s waxy, Semillon-laden plainness to something far more elegant and whole. The Pavillon Rouge was flirtatious and coquette without betraying any of its breeding. But the Grand Vin solicited a communal gasp amongst the tasters when it was brought to their lips. It was mesmerizing. One wanted to take it into a corner and make love to it—figuratively of course.
- AM+++
Overall Impression of the Margaux 2009
- VG-GR
- Overall the Margaux appellation was one of the superstars of the vintage albeit with a great amount of variation. The estates closer to the Gironde produced far more superior wines with some of those a bit more inland producing wines which are a bit more “mudddled” and unfocused. Moreover this vintage shows off how economic resources in the cellar can pay off- sure, the vintage was a naturally excellent one (re: weather-wise) but the ‘haves’ made much much better wines than the ‘have nots’ (or the ‘have less’). As far as investment in the 2009’s are concerned—they’ll appreciate, but more importantly, if you want to hold them for a while and drink them later (much later) then the ’09 Margaux may be the longest living yet (unlike the 82’s, which are dying a slow, painful and ugly death).
2009 Margaux Top 3:
- Chateau Margaux
- Chateau Palmer
- Chateau d’Issan/ Chateau Rauzan-Segla
2009 Margaux Bargains and Great Underdogs:
- Chateau Malescot-St-Exupery
- Chateau Siran
- Chateau Brane-Cantenac